Not the Paperwhite You’ve Met
Almost everybody’s first paperwhite comes in a box with a bag of pebbles, gets forced on a windowsill in December, and gets thrown away in January. That’s a real thing and a good thing, and we sell those bulbs too.
This is not that plant.
These are old-fashioned paperwhites, and I need you to hear the difference before you buy them, because if you’re expecting the forcing bulb you’ll be disappointed by the best plant on this page.
What Happened to the Paperwhites
Did you know there used to be many, many different historic types of paperwhites? At least I’ve been told that. Now we’re down to about four or five main varieties, and they’re primarily used for forcing.
The one you almost certainly know is ‘Ziva’ — an Israeli paperwhite out of the 1970s, and by far the most widely available in the world. You’ll see it called a “selection,” as though somebody walked a field and picked out the best plant. I doubt that, and here’s why.
Israel’s paperwhites came out of a deliberate government breeding program at the Volcani Center, the research arm of the Ministry of Agriculture. In 1972 that program filed a United States plant patent on a new white paperwhite, and the breeder — a man named Herut Yahel — describes it in his own words as “a seedling of two unlabelled Narcissus Paperwhite parents,” raised and split in the fields at Bet Dagan. That’s a cross, made on purpose, at a research station. I have not been able to put my hands on a document tying that particular patent to the name ‘Ziva’, so I’m not going to tell you it is one. What I’ll tell you is that the modern forcing paperwhite is a bred plant, not a lucky find.
And I want to be fair to it. That patent is careful to note that its plant can be grown out in the open air in Mediterranean climates — these aren’t hothouse invalids that die the moment they touch dirt. But look at what the forcing trade actually asks of ‘Ziva’: bloom about five weeks after planting, indoors, on schedule, for Thanksgiving or Christmas or New Year’s. Compact, upright, reliable, intense. It is very good at that. That is the job it’s sold to do, and the whole industry is built around it doing that job the same way every year.
That’s an industry, and it’s an industry that quietly replaced a whole population of garden plants. The older varieties are still out there — in older gardens and at abandoned homesites, which is exactly where we found the ones we grow.
How the Old Ones Differ
Three things, and all three matter.
1. They bloom on their own schedule. Generally from late November through the first week of January, outdoors, in the ground. Some years they are spectacular. Other years they are not. Sometimes you’ll be waiting on a bloom and a blue norther comes through and freezes the buds — the plants themselves will be fine, but it can be disappointing. And some years they do exactly what you want and give you the winter show you’ve been waiting for.
2. They aren’t compact. They’re a free-flowering, clumping form of garden flower. Don’t plan on them standing at attention and blooming tight compact heads the way forced paperwhites do. They sprawl a little. They lean. They look like something that grew rather than something that was manufactured.
3. You treat them like perennials. Let them follow the same path as your daffodils — they’re both Narcissus. Let the foliage live and die down naturally, which means greyish-green foliage in your bed through May of the following spring. If that’s going to bother you, plant them somewhere it won’t.
I mention all this so you know to treat these as garden perennials, not as florist-quality annuals in a showy pot by the front door.
Why the South Is the Right Address
These are a southern gardener’s dream — zones 8 through 11.
Paperwhites — Narcissus papyraceus — are a Mediterranean plant. Kew’s native range for the species runs Portugal, Spain, Morocco, Algeria, France, mainland Italy and Sicily, and on east into the northwest Balkans and Greece. Mild wet winters, hot dry summers. Sound familiar? That’s essentially the climate of the Deep South, the Gulf Coast, coastal California, and the warmer parts of Texas. Plant them here and you’re not fighting the plant — you’re handing it exactly what it evolved for, which is the entire thesis of everything I do.
And this isn’t only my argument. Kew’s own map shows the species running loose in Texas, Louisiana, and Alabama — not as something a gardener is tending, but as a naturalized population. A Mediterranean bulb got out into the South and simply stayed. That’s the whole case in one line on a distribution map.
Better still, they bloom in early winter, filling that quiet gap when almost nothing else in the perennial garden is doing anything at all.
The Scent Controversy
People fight about paperwhite fragrance, and there is a real compound underneath the argument — but it isn’t the one everybody names.
You’ll read all over the place that the paperwhite smell comes down to indole, the molecule in jasmine and orange blossom. I went looking for that and it doesn’t stand up for this plant. When researchers put the genus through a gas chromatograph, the three main things coming off Narcissus papyraceus were (E)-β-ocimene, benzyl acetate, and p-cresol. Indole turned up in the jonquils. It didn’t turn up in the paperwhite.
p-Cresol is the honest culprit, and it’s a better story anyway. It’s a phenol, and it is genuinely one of the compounds the nose associates with manure and barnyards. That’s the note people flinch at, and they’re not imagining it — it really is in the flower. It is also, at trace levels, something perfumers reach for on purpose. It occurs in jasmine absolute, and it’s part of what keeps a narcissus perfume smelling like an actual narcissus instead of like soap. Same molecule, doing both jobs. The dose is what’s doing the arguing. So when one person calls a bowl of paperwhites heavenly and the next one says it smells like a stable, they aren’t really disagreeing about taste. They’re disagreeing about concentration, and both noses are right.
Which is my case for growing them outdoors, and I’ll keep it modest, because I can point you to the chemistry but not to a study of anybody’s windowsill. A closed room concentrates whatever the flower is putting out and gives it nowhere to go. Open air doesn’t. Out in the yard on a December morning it reaches you and it’s gone — a surprise as you walk past, instead of a siege at the dinner table.
If you’ve decided you hate paperwhites, there’s a fair chance you’ve only ever met them in a closed room. Try one outside before you write off the plant.
Uses in the Landscape
Mix them with other winter-blooming bulbs — ‘Grand Primo’, campernelles, snowflakes — and plant them among perennial shrubs like salvias, plumbago, or lantana. The shrubs are dormant or cut back in winter, which is when the paperwhites are working, and the paperwhites’ dying foliage is hidden by the shrubs come spring. It’s a genuinely reciprocal arrangement.
Let the winter-blooming old-fashioned heirloom paperwhites fill that late-November-into-December gap. Then use the fall forcing paperwhites for formal pot combinations and annual color change-outs in the areas closest to the house. Two different plants, two different jobs. Don’t ask either one to do the other’s work.
These Are True Heirlooms
No fancy variety name here. Just an old-fashioned strain we’ve been growing at the farm for several years, collected from many different old locations. We offer a mixture of bulb sizes, and they generally bloom on the same schedule.
They multiply. A single bulb develops into a substantial clump within three to five years, and those clumps keep expanding and blooming faithfully for decades. This is why you find them still going strong at homesites where the house disappeared generations ago.
That’s the whole argument for the old ones over the new ones. ‘Ziva’ will give you a perfect flower this Christmas. These will still be blooming on this ground after you’re gone.
Planting & Care
When: You can wait, but why would you? Plant them now and let the ground protect them — plus you won’t forget about them. The bulbs are dormant, but planting now gives them time to settle in before they send up blooms this coming winter. If you really want to wait until fall, you can; just keep them out of direct sunlight where air can flow around them.
Depth and sun: Plant two to three times as deep as the bulb is tall, in well-drained soil, with 6+ hours of winter sun.
Foliage: Let it die down naturally. Greyish-green leaves through May are the price of admission and they’re what pays for next December.
Why Nothing Eats Them
Deer, squirrels, voles, rabbits, and gophers leave paperwhites alone, and that’s one of the great practical arguments for this whole family. Plant them and forget the critter worries.
Let me say why accurately, though, because the catalogs tend to say it wrong. Nothing is getting poisoned in your yard. The animals are refusing the bulb. Narcissus bulbs carry lycorine and related alkaloids — bitter, irritating, and sickening if something does get a mouthful down — and one taste settles the matter for good. The mechanism is rejection, not a body count.
And that chemistry doesn’t check whether the animal is wild. Paperwhite bulbs are toxic to dogs, cats, and horses, and every so often somebody cooks narcissus bulbs having mistaken them for onions and spends the evening being violently sick — there’s a documented cluster of exactly that in England and a long run of cases in Japan. Vomiting is the usual end of it and rarely worse. But don’t keep a sack of bulbs where a dog or a curious kid can get into it, and think twice about where you set a forcing bowl if you’ve got a cat.
The rejection is a big part of why heirloom clumps persist for a century or more. The house falls in, the family leaves, the fence goes down, every hungry thing in the county walks through — and the paperwhites keep blooming every December for nobody at all.
Shop this variety at SouthernBulbs.com
Shop Old-Fashioned Paperwhites →
Starting at $15.00